Fourth Amendment · Tennessee v. Garner (1985)
Police shooting and deadly force investigations
Independent investigation of shootings and other deadly force, for families and their attorneys.
In Tennessee v. Garner (1985), the Supreme Court held that deadly force may not be used against a fleeing person unless the officer has probable cause to believe the person poses a significant threat of death or serious physical injury. After a shooting, the official account is usually written by the agency whose officer fired. Families and their attorneys are entitled to an independent look at the evidence.
What an investigation looks for
- Where each person stood and moved, reconstructed from the scene, video, and physical evidence
- Whether the person was armed, what was in their hands, and what the officers could see
- The timing of commands, warnings, and shots, taken from audio, video, and dispatch records
- Witnesses the official investigation did not interview, and evidence it did not collect
How these cases are investigated
In police shooting and deadly force cases, the work most often involves scene investigation, video and digital evidence recovery, independent case review, and witness location and interviews. What a particular case needs depends on what evidence already exists and what is at risk of being lost.
Nationwide, and civil rights only
Evidence in police shooting and deadly force cases is lost quickly. Video is overwritten, records are purged, and witnesses move on. Civil Rights PI accepts these investigations nationwide, and the earlier the work begins, the more there is to find.
How it is investigated
Services these cases rely on
Scene Investigation & Documentation
The place where it happened, measured, photographed, and diagrammed, so a judge or jury can see what each person could see, hear, and reach.
Learn moreWitness Location & Interviews
Finding the people who saw what happened, including those the official report left out, and recording what they know while they still remember it.
Learn moreVideo & Digital Evidence
Body camera, dash camera, surveillance, doorbell, and mobile phone video, located and preserved before it is overwritten, then assembled into a single timeline.
Learn moreIndependent Case Review & Reinvestigation
A second, independent look at the official investigation: what was done, what was left undone, and where the report and the evidence disagree.
Learn moreMore case types